Current News

/

ArcaMax

Lindsay Clancy's triple-murder retrial scheduled for March

Colleen Cronin, Boston Herald on

Published in News & Features

PLYMOUTH, Mass. — Lindsay Clancy’s retrial is on the court calendar for next March — with prosecutors hinting that she’ll face first-degree murder charges again.

At a status conference in Plymouth Superior Court Monday, Judge William Sullivan scheduled her second triple-murder trial for March 29, 2027. Clancy is accused of strangling her three children, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, eight months, in January 2023 before trying to kill herself by jumping out of a second-story window.

She was tried over the summer for three counts of first degree murder, but Sullivan declared a mistrial in September after the jury couldn’t come to a unanimous decision.

“From the Commonwealth’s perspective, given what the charges are, it requires a jury,” Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague said in court. “We haven’t heard from defense counsel about any other direction for the trial.” In Massachusetts, first-degree murder cases must be tried by a jury rather than by a judge alone.

“The die is cast,” Clancy’s defense attorney Kevin Reddington said, calling the comment from Sprague an indirect announcement that Clancy will face the maximum charges and penalties. First-degree murder comes with a mandatory life sentence without the possibility of parole.

The Herald has reached out to the Plymouth DA’s Office for further comment.

DA Timothy Cruz “is not showing his hand, as he is entitled,” Retired Superior Court Judge Jack Lu told the Herald.

“The prosecutor could still lower the charges even at the last minute,” he explained.

During Clancy’s first trial, prosecutors sought to paint an image of a calculated crime, claiming that Clancy planned the killings in an effort to get out of a life she no longer wanted.

Reddington didn’t dispute that Clancy did the killings; instead, he argued that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time and isn’t criminally responsible for the deaths.

After a week of deliberations, jurors reported that they ended up deadlocked 11 to one, with the majority of the panel moving to acquit Clancy.

The case became a media frenzy by the time Sullivan declared a mistrial, but in Plymouth on Monday, that feeling was subdued.

There were fewer reporters and members of the public in the audience. DA Cruz also wasn’t in the courtroom.

During the short hearing, Reddington, Sprague, and Judge Sullivan mostly bickered about scheduling and quoted Shakespeare.

The prosecution asked for a May trial date, citing other proceedings.

“I have trials all over the state,” Reddington fired back, before asking for an April trial instead.

Sullivan, who is required to retire when he turns 70 next year, urged the parties to come up with an earlier date.

“Mr. Reddington quoted Julius Caesar,” Sullivan said, “I would quote Shakespeare. We can’t go “tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow, creeps upon its petty pace.’”

“This is the case that’s in front of me right now, I want to get this done,” the judge added, noting that getting it done sooner is “better for all the parties.”

 

As Sullivan threw out dates, Sprague said there were conflicts either for her or ADA Shanan Buckingham.

“Keeping with historical quotes, we can do March 15?” Sullivan asked.

“Sorry, I don’t have any jokes,” Sprague replied.

“I’m not saying any jokes, all right?” Sullivan said, raising his voice for a moment. “I’m just trying to talk to both counsel about getting a date.”

At one point, Sprague said that one of the dates wouldn’t give Buckingham enough time to prepare because she was coming off another murder trial.

“We’ve already tried it for seven weeks,” Reddington quipped.

“We have a right to present it in a different manner,” she countered.

Ultimately, Sullivan set the trial for March 29, over the Commonwealth’s objection.

Outside the courthouse after the hearing, Reddington and his co-counsel Laura McConnell responded to questions from a scrum of reporters.

Reddington said that he feels bad for his client, her parents, and any future jurors.

“I feel bad for anyone that has to do with this case,” he said, telling reporters that Clancy was nervous. “She’s very, very sensitive right now, this is a tough day for her.”

The defense attorney said that today was the first time he heard the prosecution would be moving forward with first degree. When asked why the DA wasn’t announcing the charges outright, Reddington said, “walk into his office and ask them.”

He pushed back on the idea that a plea deal could be on the table. “I don’t think they’d give me the right time of day at this point,” he said.

While Clancy’s criminal case proceeds, another of her lawyers, Martin Weinberg, has filed an appeal to the Supreme Judicial Court, arguing that her case should be dismissed based on double jeopardy grounds.

That motion in Superior Court was denied by Judge Sullivan last week.

Clancy’s next pretrial hearing is set for Dec. 30.

_____


©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at bostonherald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus